We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track. If this problem persists help us by reporting it so we can investigate it.
Gems
Collections
The universe
If the bird and I are one, why can’t I see the world through the bird’s eyes?
Watch the full talk
Login or create a free account to watch this talk and discover other teachings from Zen Master Thich Nhat Hanh.
Log in or create an account
Subtitles
Subtitle Size
Subtitle Placement
Playback Speed
Questions and Answers
Questions and Answers
Thich Nhat Hanh
· August 25, 2006
· Upper Hamlet, Plum Village, France
Not yet reviewed
The title, description and transcript may contain inaccuracies.
Questions & Answers, No description yet, ‘suggest edit’ to add one.
Part of the following collections
9 videos
1h 38m
Everyday Family Relationships and Renewal
From the Living Gems Curation Team
6 videos
34m
Now playing
The universe
Curated by
David van Leeuwen
6 videos
11h 21m
Scientists in the Field of Consciousness — 2006
From the Living Gems Curation Team
14 videos
2h 10m
Responding to War with Peace
From the Living Gems Curation Team
Next:
Buddhism and Science
Next from:
The universe
6m
Buddhism and Science
From
"Public Talk"
• August 14, 2011
3/6
•
Autoplay next:
Off
Transcript
View chapters
Expand transcript
Preparing, video will start to follow where you are in the transcript shortly.
Scroll back to current moment in transcript
View Complete Transcript
An
important
place
where
I
believe
science
may
meet
Buddhism
is
when
looking
deeply
into
the
nature
of
space
and
time
and
their
relationship
to
consciousness.
So
the
question
I'm
going
to
ask
may
seem
a
little
crazy
coming
from
a
scientist,
but
its
aim
is
to
help
me
deepen
my
understanding
on
this
issue
in
the
light
of
non-self.
When
I
look
at
a
bird
sitting
on
the
branch
of
a
tree
and
listen
to
his
singing,
and
this
singing
brings
up
a
smile
in
me,
I
can
see
in
that
smile
that
I'm
not
separate
from
the
bird.
However,
it
seems
that
the
point
of
view
on
reality
that
I
have
access
to
through
my
senses,
my
here
and
now,
appears
different
from
the
point
of
view
the
bird
has
access
to
through
his
eyes,
from
his
place
and
time.
So
what
seems
to
make
up
my
self
is
a
particular
point
of
view
on
reality
which
seems
different
from
the
point
of
view
of
any
other
being
or
entity,
whether
it
be
a
bird,
another
human
being,
a
sunflower,
a
stone,
a
chair,
or
even
a
cell
of
my
own
body.
So
here
comes
the
crazy
question.
Since
I
and
the
bird
are
not
separate,
are
one,
since
we
are
one,
how
come
I
cannot
sense,
I
cannot
see
the
world,
I
cannot
see
things
through
the
eyes
of
the
bird?
And
I
mean,
not
just
by
an
indirect
way
through
imagination,
but
directly.
How
come
I
cannot
see
the
world
through
the
eyes
of
the
bird,
and
how
come
I
cannot
seem
to
feel
the
wind
on
his
wings?
Yeah,
I
like
crazy
questions.
Because
in
Buddhism
there
are
many
things
that
look
crazy
like
that
also,
like
non-self,
no
self.
While
everyone
believes
that
there
is
a
self,
and
the
Buddha
said
there
is
no
self.
Quite
a
crazy
idea.
But
very
helpful.
It
makes
us
not
too
sure
of
ourselves,
and
that
is
a
possibility
of
advancing
on
our
path
of
understanding.
You
know,
and
the
scientists
also
confirm
that
our
brain
is
a
social
brain.
Our
brain
is
made
of
other
brains.
During
the
time
we
were
still
in
the
womb
of
our
mother,
that
already
started
to
work
like
that.
And
during
the
first
six
years
of
our
life,
during
the
development
of
our
brain,
we
received
the
non-self
elements,
non-brain
elements
in
order
to
form
our
brain.
So
physically,
our
brain
is
a
social
brain.
And
as
far
as
consciousness,
the
same
thing
is
true.
Our
consciousness
is
somehow
a
collective
consciousness.
Your
idea
of
beauty
or
ugliness
is
not
your
own,
but
you
have
been
influenced
by
the
idea
of
beauty
and
ugliness
of
the
others.
When
you
go
to
a
department
store
and
buy
a
shirt
or
a
necktie,
you
think
that
you
make
the
decision
which
one
is
more
beautiful,
which
one
suits
you.
But
you
don't
know
that
underneath,
it
is
not
exactly
who
decides.
Your
decision
has
been
influenced
by
the
view,
by
the
feeling,
the
idea
of
beauty
or
ugliness
of
other
people.
So
there
is
nothing
as
an
individual
brain.
There
is
nothing
as
an
individual
consciousness.
And
you
cannot
be
sure
that
it
is
your
way
of
feeling,
that
feeling.
We
know
that
there
are
trillions
of
cells
in
our
body.
And
every
cell,
not
only
the
nervous
cell,
has
its
own
brain,
has
its
own
feeling.
I
learned
that
each
cell
has
a
membrane.
And
the
membrane
has
the
capacity
of
receiving
information
and
making
decisions.
And
each
cell
has
its
own
brain.
And
our
brain
is
not
just
in
the
skull.
In
the
heart,
there
is
another
brain.
And
we
know
that
more
than
sixty
percent
of
the
cells
in
the
heart
are
neurons.
And
our
enteric
system
is
also
another
brain.
Our
anxiety,
our
feeling
are
much
more
here
than
here.
So
I
like
to
think
that
there
is
a
community
of
cells
that
cohabit,
that
coexist,
and
together
they
produce
that
feeling.
That
feeling
is
a
collective
feeling,
not
exactly
your
feeling.
There
is
no
you.
It
is
a
collective
feeling.
And
you
know
that
there
are
trillions
of
human
cells
in
our
body.
But
there
are
more,
there
are
also
trillions
of
cells
that
are
not
human.
And
they
coexist.
And
their
feelings
are
very
much
participating
in
what
you
call
your
feelings.
So
many,
many
brains
are
within,
and
they
combine.
And
you
know
that
inside
of
our
cells,
there
are
mitochondria.
And
their
DNA
is
quite
different
from
ours.
And
they
are
at
the
center
of
our
cells.
And
without
them,
we
would
have
no
energy
in
order
to
think,
to
feel,
to
speak.
And
so
you
cannot
be
sure
that
it
is
your
idea,
your
feeling.
The
notion
of
self
should
be
reconsidered.
So
there
is
a
feeling,
yes.
There
are
feelings,
yes.
But
to
say
that
it
is
my
feeling
or
your
feeling,
I
am
not
very
sure.
And
the
membrane
is
a
kind
of
brain.
I
like
to
say
that
our
brain
is
non-local.
It
is
not
situated
here.
It
is
all
over
our
body,
and
it
is
also
out
of
our
body,
outside
our
body.
Mind
is
non-local.
But
brain,
to
my
understanding,
is
also
non-local.
You
cannot
situate
the
locality
of
your
brain,
even
if
you
are
using
EEG,
MRI,
and
so
on.
And
each
membrane
is
a
member
of
the
brain
community.
Mem-brane.
And
each
membrane
contributes
its
perception,
its
insight,
its
feeling.
And
what
you
call
your
feeling
is
their
feelings
also.
And
that
is
to
say
only
about
human
cells.
But
there
are
more
non-human
cells
in
us,
and
they
do
have
their
feelings,
their
perceptions.
And
your
perception
is
their
perception.
And
that
is
why
I
am
sure
that
the
feeling
of
the
bird,
the
perception
of
the
bird
is
somewhere
in
your
perception.
There
is
no
separation.
This
is
an
invitation
for
scientists
to
work
harder.
Thank
you.
View Complete Transcript